Skip to main content

The Whisper

The Whisper is the sci-fi middle-grade sequel to The Roar, by Emma Clayton.

You know the drill, bibliophiles. If you haven’t read The Roar, you don’t want to read a review on the sequel – it’ll just give stuff away. So, avert thine eyes.

All the rest of you who HAVE read The Roar, you’ll find a spoiler-free review below…

Mika and Ellie didn’t know if they’d ever see each other again – but the day has finally come. The circumstances, though, aren’t so good…

They’re mutants – a new kind of child that has special abilities, can do things ordinary children can’t do. And that has made them valuable to one devious man: Mal Gorman.

His plan is to take over the beauty of wilderness and riches on the other side of The Wall – where everyone behind The Wall has been told is scorched and impossible to live on.

It’s all been lies.

Mika and Ellie have to pretend to be submissive, to agree with his plan – it’s the only way they can figure out a plan on how to save the rest of the kids – Gorman’s brainwashed, micro chipped army.

But what Gorman doesn’t know is that Mika and Ellie can hear The Whisper – and they’re determined to keep any the war from starting…

I liked The Roar quite a bit. It flip-flopped about a bit, but it was consistently entertaining and held a different tone for a sci-fi novel. So, I was looking forward to where the story would go from here.

Yet right when The Whisper opens with an odd, standoffish third-person narration, providing background and recap in a way that made me think of a stiff voiceover, I was surprised to find a change. All the parts with the twins’ seemed normal, but everything else, especially involving Tom and the other kids, felt off.

Though The Whisper still has a compelling, intriguing story it felt clunkier and more uneven. Despite there being more disturbing moments that heighten the stakes, I had too many “but’s”. For example, one second The Whisper was more political than I prefer since it seemed like the author might be pushing her views in a non-subtle way when I just want to be told a good story and the next second the book was merging on cartoonish with the villain Mal Gorman. So, each time it seemed like it was improving, it changed course again.

Plus, some of the mechanics of The Whisper were bugging me. Like, I don’t understand how they kept birds and bugs from flying over The Wall – is this a gigantic plot hole, or did I miss something?

Sadly, I was disappointed in The Whisper. It’s really too bad because it clearly has good intentions, but it went beyond where I expected the story to go in a strangely pessimistic way, in my opinion.

But don’t listen to me! If you were a fan of The Roar too, read The Whisper! We are all different, and you may find that The Whisper meets all your expectations and more!!


Popular posts from this blog

Real Live Boyfriends

Real Live Boyfriends is a YA contemporary novel by E. Lockhart, and the fourth novel in the Ruby Oliver quartet.

Here we are on the last day of “Ruby Oliver Week” and if you aren’t already reading these books – well, why not?

But I’m more than sure most of you are – and hopefully you’re all caught up, and therefore not at risk of being spoiled by my review of Real Live Boyfriends. You’ve been warned!

Ruby Oliver is beginning her senior year of high school with a real live boyfriend: Noel.

At least she thought she was.

After having spent the rest of junior year and the beginning of summer being fully in love (okay, they never actually said the word, but the vibes were strongly in that direction), Ruby is now confused.


When Noel went to visit his brother in New York for a while, almost every day they talked on the phone and exchanged funny emails. She never once felt insecure.

Until all of a sudden – communication stopped. Ruby would call and he wouldn’t answer. She’d leave a voice mai…

Interview with Joanna Philbin!

Today we have an extra special guest! Joanna Philbin, author of The Daughters series, is here to tell us about the fourth and (*sniff*) final book in the series - The Daughters Join the Party - as well as answer some other questions!

Welcome to the Bibliophile Support Group, Joanna! We're happy to have you!

So, for anybody who hasn't read the first three books in The Daughters series (read my reviews here: The Daughters, The Daughters Break the Rules, The Daughters Take the Stage) can you give everybody a general idea of what they're about?

Lizzie, Carina, and Hudson are best friends who are normal fourteen year-old girls in almost every way. Except for one: each girl has a parent who is incredibly famous. And her parent’s fame complicates her life in a big way. Lizzie’s mom is a supermodel, but Lizzie isn’t what most people would call “beautiful” – in fact, she’s what most people might call “unusual-looking.” How do you deal with having a supermodel mother when you don’t …

#YAStandsFor Daily Social Challenge... Day 5!

In my final day of participating in the I Read YA Week celebration (you can keep partying, it goes on through Monday!), I found myself presented with a new challenge of: Create a graphic showcasing an inspirational YA quote.

I'm not super tech savvy and I've never created a graphic before. But with just a little Google searching and a download of an app, I was able to create this:

Thanks for joining me this week! I hope you all enjoyed it! Please follow or subscribe for notifications of new posts and reviews upcoming on the Bibliophile Support Group!